When it comes time to plan the upcoming set list, I bet you spend time wondering if it is too soon to schedule the same song again…I mean, it has only been two weeks since the last time it was scheduled.

To tell you the truth, I struggle with the same thought almost every week.

I was talking with a fellow worship leader a few days ago about this very subject. We were about to lead a night of worship together and were discussing whether or not to play the opener song again at the end.

We decided to do just that and it turned out really well. The congregation engaged just as much (if not more) the second time we played the song. (For those of you who are wondering, the song was Shout It Out by Vertical Church Band.)

Song recurrence really doesn’t matter.

So, this got me thinking…we as worship leaders tend to overthink how often we play a specific song.

Did you ever notice that most people listen to the same songs every day on the radio? Even if they don’t listen to the radio, I bet they replay the same iTunes playlist or Pandora channel over and over. This is a good indicator that how often we schedule a song should not be a determining factor in our song selection.

What should we consider when planning the set list?

  • The Still Small Voice – I believe the Holy Spirit gently leads us to the songs we should sing each Sunday. There are many who think He will only do this on Sunday morning, but considering He knows the future, I am pretty sure He can guide us ahead of time as well.
  • Engagement – Every new song goes through a three-week trial period at my church. If the congregation is still not engaging with the song after three consecutive weeks, it gets retired for good. Removing non-engaging songs from your list of available songs will help tremendously when you are planning the set list.
  • Flow – Have you ever scheduled a set list that didn’t flow? Maybe the song themes didn’t fit together or the different keys didn’t gel. There are many things that lead to a set list that feels broken, so be sure to spend time thinking through song transitions and how the songs relate to each other. You don’t want to leave room for the congregation to get distracted between songs.

Moral of the story, don’t let unimportant things like song recurrence distract you from planning the right set list for your church.

On top of this, be sure to relax when you are planning the set list. Don’t worry yourself about finding the ‘perfect’ set list. In the end, as long as the congregation is singing Biblically-sound songs, they will leave better than they were before.

You might also be interested in: The Benefits of a Shorter Set List

Join the Worship Leader Community

Get our latest and best content delivered right to your inbox!

Join the conversation! 5

About the Author

Kade Young

Kade Young brought Collaborate Worship into existence with a dream of helping worship leaders around the world fulfill their calling with excellence. He has been leading worship since 2005, is a graduate of Rhema Bible Training College, and currently the worship leader at NoLimits Church in Owasso, Oklahoma.